Orbital cellulitis is a clinical diagnosis. Once the diagnosis is made, an empirical antibiotic is started, and in most cases, the clinical improvement can be observed within 24-48 hours. We discuss treatment options in managing orbital cellulitis in a 34-year-old male in which no improvement was seen despite being started on empirical broad-spectrum antibiotic. Patient had a prior history of being bitten by an insect in the left upper eyelid while doing gardening about 5 days prior to admission. The patient developed left orbital cellulitis a few days following the insect bite. Patient was started empirical broad-spectrum antibiotic immediately, but no improvement observed. Culture and sensitivity taken from the upper eyelid grew methicillin-resistance Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) which was sensitive to vancomycin. Patient was treated with intensive fourteen days of intravenous vancomycin. The infection resolved as evidenced by clinical improvement and reduction of white blood cells count.